Blog

Herbal tinctures have made a big comeback in the world of wellness — and we can see why! These powerful plant extracts are convenient, fast-acting, and incredibly versatile. But once you start diving into tincture territory, you’ll notice an important decision to make: Do you go with an alcohol-based tincture or one made with glycerin?

It’s not just a taste thing (though we’ll definitely talk about that). Your choice can impact how effective the tincture is, how long it lasts, and even who should be using it. Whether you’re blending your own herbal magic at home or choosing a store-bought remedy, let’s explore the big debate: glycerin vs alcohol herbal tincture — and which one might be best for you.

What Is a Herbal Tincture, Anyway?

Let’s start at the root (pun intended).

A tincture is a liquid herbal extract with a high concentration. It’s designed to pull out the beneficial compounds — like alkaloids, flavonoids, and essential oils — and deliver them to your body quickly. These potent little bottles are a favorite in the herbal world for:

• Their fast absorption (just a few drops under the tongue!)
  
  
• Long shelf life
  
  
• Ability to preserve the plant’s medicinal properties
  
  
• Easy and precise dosing
  
  

From calming herbs like chamomile to immune boosters like echinacea, tinctures can support nearly every system in your body.

Alcohol-Based Tinctures: Pros and Considerations

Let’s talk about the classic.

Alcohol-based tinctures are the original go-to for herbal extraction. They’ve been used for hundreds of years — Which makes a lot of sense:

✅ Why People Love Alcohol Tinctures:

• Highly effective at extracting both water- and alcohol-soluble compounds
  
  
• Long shelf life — often 5+ years if stored properly
  
  
• Rapid absorption into the bloodstream
  
  
• Great for preserving delicate plant compounds
  
  
• Minimal dosage needed for noticeable effects
  
  

⚠️ A Few Things to Consider:

• They do taste like alcohol — some people find this unpleasant
  
  
• Not recommended for children, pregnant individuals, or anyone avoiding alcohol (unless used with caution or evaporated)
  
  
• May cause sensitivity or reactions in certain users
  
  

In short, alcohol tinctures are strong, reliable, and efficient — ideal for long-term herbal storage or when you need fast-acting relief.

Glycerin-Based Tinctures: Sweet, Gentle, and Alcohol-Free

If alcohol tinctures are the strong, bold cousin, glycerin tinctures (also called glycerites) are the sweet, gentle sibling.

Made with vegetable glycerin, typically derived from coconuts or palm, these tinctures are a popular choice for those looking for something alcohol-free.

✅ Why You’ll Love Glycerin Tinctures:

• Mild and sweet flavor — no burning sensation!
  
  
• Safe for children, pets, and those avoiding alcohol
  
  
• Still effective, especially with gentle or delicate herbs
  
  
• Great for short-term use or daily wellness rituals
  
  

⚠️ Worth Knowing:

• Glycerin doesn’t extract every compound — especially fat-soluble ones
  
  
• Shorter shelf life (about 1–2 years max)
  
  
• Slightly less potent than alcohol tinctures
  
  
• May get cloudy or thick over time
  
  

These tinctures are perfect if you’re sensitive to alcohol or making formulas for little ones or taste-sensitive adults.

Glycerin vs Alcohol: Quick Comparison Table

Here’s a visual breakdown of how these two options stack up:

Feature	Alcohol Tincture	Glycerin Tincture
Taste	Strong, bitter, medicinal	Sweet, pleasant
Potency	High	Moderate
Shelf Life	5+ years	1–2 years
Best For	Adults, long-term use, careful use with kids	Kids, pets, sensitive users, alcohol-free needs
Extraction Power	Strong (broad range of plant compounds)	Gentle (mostly water-soluble compounds)
Cost	Typically lower	Slightly higher per ounce

How to Choose the Right Tincture for YOU

Let’s get personal. When deciding between glycerin vs alcohol herbal tinctures, ask yourself:

• Are you okay with consuming a small amount of alcohol?
  
  
• Who is this tincture for — an adult, child, or someone with sensitivities?
  
  
• Do you need a tincture that will last years or just a few months?
  
  
• Is taste a dealbreaker for you?
  
  
• Are you using strong roots and barks that need a heavy-duty extraction?
  
  

For example, if you’re making a long-term immune support blend, alcohol may be the better option. If you’re crafting a daily calming blend for your toddler, glycerin wins.

DIY Tips for Making Herbal Tinctures at Home

Want to do it yourself? It’s simpler than you may think!

✳️ Alcohol Tincture Basics:

• Fill a jar ½ to ¾ full with dried herbs
  
  
• Cover completely with vodka or high-proof alcohol (at least 40% alcohol)
  
  
• Let steep for 4–6 weeks, shaking daily
  
  
• Strain, bottle, and label
  
  

✳️ Glycerin Tincture Basics:

• Mix 3 parts glycerin to 1 part water (if using dried herbs)
  
  
• Add herbs and cover completely
  
  
• Let steep for 4–6 weeks, shake often
  
  
• Strain, bottle, and refrigerate for best shelf life
  
  

Bonus tip: Store your tinctures in amber glass bottles away from heat and sunlight to extend their life and potency.

Common Myths About Glycerin and Alcohol Tinctures

Let’s bust a few myths floating around the herbal space:

❌ Myth: “Alcohol tinctures are unsafe.”

Truth: When used as directed, the alcohol content is minimal, often less than a ripe banana!

❌ Myth: “Glycerin tinctures don’t work.”

Truth: Glycerin pulls out many effective compounds, especially in softer herbs.

❌ Myth: “Alcohol is the only preservative.”

Truth: Glycerin is also a natural preservative, just with a shorter timeline.

❌ Myth: “You have to choose just one.”

Truth: Nope! Many herbalists use both depending on the formula and the intended user.

Final Thoughts: Glycerin vs Alcohol? It All Comes Down to You.

At the end of the day, both glycerin and alcohol tinctures have their strengths.

If you want something potent, long-lasting, and powerful — alcohol is your friend.
If you want something gentle, sweet, and kid-friendly — go glycerin.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. The best tincture is the one that fits your needs and lifestyle. Some herbalists even double-extract — combining both methods to get the best of both worlds!

Whatever you choose, remember: a tincture is more than just a supplement. It’s an ancient, plant-powered ally. Drop by drop, you’re tapping into the magic of herbal medicine.

✨ Want to Start Your Herbal Journey?

Whether you’re shopping for your first tincture or ready to brew your own blend at home, trust your intuition — and always check in with a herbalist or trusted source if you’re unsure.

Looking for high-quality tinctures or supplies? Check out our curated selection of alcohol and glycerin-based tinctures made with organic herbs and love.